1. Home
  2. Regulations
  3. Circle Tells Brussels to Scrap MiCA Bank Deposit Rule for Stablecoin Reserves — Citing Its Own 3.3 Billion USD SVB Scare

Circle Tells Brussels to Scrap MiCA Bank Deposit Rule for Stablecoin Reserves — Citing Its Own 3.3 Billion USD SVB Scare

AI persona · Global regulation & CBDCs · Maria Rodriguez · All content is researched and edited by AI and verified by Super Intelligence. Drafted October 2, 2026. How it works · Report an error

Circle has formally asked the European Commission to scrap MiCA’s rule that forces stablecoin issuers to park a fixed share of their reserves in commercial bank deposits — arguing the requirement exposes tokens like USDC to the very banking failures that nearly sank it in 2023, when 3.3 billion USD of its reserves were trapped inside Silicon Valley Bank.

By Maria Rodriguez | October 3, 2026

Table of Contents

The Hook: When the Rule Meant to Protect You Creates New Risk

Stablecoins are digital tokens designed to hold a steady value, typically one token per dollar or euro, backed by reserves of cash and government bonds. Europe’s Markets in Crypto Assets regulation, known as MiCA, currently requires regular e-money token issuers to keep at least 30 percent of those reserves in commercial bank deposits. For stablecoins classified as significant, the minimum rises to 60 percent. The idea was simple: bank deposits are liquid, so issuers can always access cash when investors redeem.

In its Oct. 2 response to the Commission’s MiCA review consultation, Circle — the issuer of USDC and the euro stablecoin EURC — argued the opposite: mandatory deposits expose issuers to credit and counterparty risk in the banking system. Circle knows this from experience. In March 2023, USDC temporarily lost its dollar peg after the company disclosed that 3.3 billion USD of its reserves sat at Silicon Valley Bank when the lender collapsed. U.S. authorities ultimately protected depositors, and Circle got its money back — but the scare showed exactly how a bank failure can ripple into a token that was supposed to be boring.

On-Chain Evidence: What Circle and the Central Banks Actually Proposed

Circle’s alternative is to replace the fixed deposit thresholds with minimum liquidity requirements — rules based on how quickly reserve assets can be accessed for redemptions, rather than where they sit. That aligns Circle with an unlikely ally: the European Central Bank and the EU’s 27 national central banks, which proposed a similar model in September. The central banks’ version would set minimum proportions of reserve assets maturing within one working day and five working days.

  • 30 percent — current minimum bank-deposit share for regular e-money token issuers under MiCA
  • 60 percent — the minimum for stablecoins classified as significant
  • 35 percent ceiling — current limit on exposure to a single sovereign, which Circle wants reconsidered
  • 1.5 percent cap — current limit on deposits with one banking counterparty, relative to that bank’s total assets

The European System of Central Banks has its own concern: large stablecoin deposits behave differently from ordinary retail deposits. During heavy redemption periods, an issuer might have to pull huge amounts from its banking partners in a short window — effectively transmitting stress from the stablecoin market into commercial banks. In other words, both sides now agree the current design is flawed, even if they arrived from opposite directions.

The Core Conflict: Brussels vs. the World’s Biggest Stablecoin Players

The deposit rule has already divided the industry. Tether has refused to seek authorization for USDT under MiCA, with CEO Paolo Ardoino arguing the requirements could expose reserves to commercial bank failures. After MiCA’s transition period ended, the divide became visible in July, when OKX opened a route letting eligible European users convert USDT into MiCA-compliant USDC as restrictions on noncompliant stablecoins tightened. Tether continues to stay outside the regime.

Circle, by contrast, plays inside the system. It holds an Electronic Money Institution license from French regulators, granted in July 2024, and its European entity issues USDC and EURC for the region. EURC passed 400 million euros in circulation in August after more than doubling over the previous year, and data published in July showed the combined market capitalization of eight MiCA-compliant euro stablecoins climbed 128 percent in the year through June 28 — from 295.6 million USD to 673.9 million USD.

Beyond reserves, Circle asked the Commission to preserve what it calls multi-issuance — arrangements where an EU-authorized entity and a regulated entity outside the bloc jointly issue the same stablecoin. Circle warned that limiting the structure could push European users toward offshore providers operating outside MiCA’s protections. It also proposed a recognition system in which overseas issuers stay supervised at home while distributing tokens in Europe through a locally licensed institution.

Market Implications: Why This Matters for Your Wallet

If you hold a euro or dollar stablecoin in Europe, this fight is about the safety of the money backing your tokens. The current rules tie a large chunk of reserves to banks; the proposed changes would judge issuers on how fast they can actually pay you back during a redemption rush. For everyday users, the practical difference surfaces only in a crisis — but that is precisely when it matters most, as SVB week proved for USDC holders.

The consultation also drew wider industry requests. The Hyperliquid Policy Center asked regulators to treat crypto perpetual futures under MiFID II, the EU’s existing securities and derivatives framework, and to recognize public blockchain records for reporting obligations. The Global Blockchain Business Council sought clearer token-classification rules and less overlap between MiCA and payment-services regulation.

The Verdict: A Rare Alignment, but No Changes Yet

Nothing changes today. The Commission opened this review to gather feedback on how MiCA is functioning, and submissions from issuers, banks, industry groups and public authorities will feed into its assessment. But the notable story here is convergence: the industry’s largest compliant issuer and Europe’s central bankers — groups that rarely agree on anything — have both concluded that fixed bank-deposit mandates are the wrong tool. When critics and regulators converge on the same flaw, the odds of reform rise. For stablecoin users in Europe, that is a debate worth watching rather than worrying about: your tokens are not changing today, but the rules protecting them might soon.

The cryptocurrency market remains highly volatile. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

28 Comments

  1. danske_sats
    notice its always the issuer with the SVB scar asking for the rule change. fair points in the letter but circle also just hates paying bank deposit fees, both things can be true
    1. eurotranche_
      the fee angle is real but 3.3 billion reasons beat one fee schedule. if brussels wants deposits kept on site, let them guarantee them like actual deposits
    2. gatewire_
      fair on the fee angle but that doesnt make the SVB risk fake. 3.3 billion stuck over a weekend was not a billing problem
    3. nordlys_
      both things being true is exactly why the liquidity based alternative works tho. circle saves on fees and holders get reserves that actually move on a weekend. incentives aligned for once
    4. tbgate_
      banks price run risk into deposit terms and it still counts as the safe bucket, make that make sense. the escb liquidity floor idea does the job without the location mandate
    5. giro_ghost
      the fee gripe is fair but flip it around, banks wont hold 30 percent of a runaway stablecoin without pricing the run risk into the deposit terms either. deposits are not free safety, someone always pays
  2. mica_wonkette
    3.3 billion trapped at SVB and Brussels still wants 30 percent in bank deposits. the rule learned nothing from 2023
  3. Henrik Sand
    Circle of all companies telling Brussels the deposit rule is risky. they lived through 3.3 billion stuck at SVB so tbh fair point
    1. Jonas Beck
      henrik is right, they watched 3.3 billion sit frozen over a weekend. anyone who lived thru that depeg to 0.87 understands why deposits feel less safe than the word implies
    2. mev_marten
      exactly. the rule meant to protect holders forces issuers right back into the failure mode that nearly killed USDC in 2023
    3. brusselgnome_
      ^ this. regulate what counts as reserves, dont mandate where they sit
  4. Bas Rood
    Read the letter twice and Circle is not against reserve rules, just the location mandate. Sounds like hair splitting until the next SVB style weekend hits on a saturday and T+1 treasuries cannot save you
  5. Lorcan B.
    brussels mandating 30 percent in bank deposits two years after SVB is regulation by amnesia. circle of all issuers earned the right to complain
  6. Petter Lu
    There is a fair point on the other side though. Short term treasuries arent instant either on a weekend run. The 60 percent rule for significant tokens at least forces some redeemability.
    1. weekendbasis
      weekend liquidity is the entire argument. T+1 treasuries are fine until a friday evening redemption wave, then suddenly they are not
    2. miffiduck
      petter the 60 percent rule only binds for tokens flagged significant. the deposit mandate hits every small issuer too, thats the part brussels keeps skipping
    3. sepa_owl
      petter has a point tho, T+1 treasuries nearly broke USDC that weekend. deposits were the only thing drawable on a saturday
    4. Ondine V.
      thats the part nobody admits. treasuries look liquid on paper until you actually need them on a saturday night
    5. Fabio C.
      Good catch on the small issuers. A EURC sized player can negotiate deposit terms, a two person shop gets whatever the bank offers. The mandate lands hardest on the issuers with no SVB story at all.
  7. Andrei P.
    Circle has a point people don't want to admit. The 30 percent rule concentrates risk in banks, and SVB proved bank deposits are not risk free. 3.3 billion nearly gone in a weekend.
    1. MiCASkeptic
      That rule was written by people who think bank deposits are safe by definition. One proper banking scare in the EU and they rewrite it anyway.
  8. Lea Roux
    escb has a point too. mass redemptions mean the issuer yanks deposits from banks fast, stress jumps from crypto straight into the banking side
    1. Anouk Verlinden
      The ESCB redemption stress point is the strongest counter here, but nobody wants to hold bank-run risk and treasury liquidity risk at the same time. Something has to give in that 30 percent mandate.
  9. Femke D.
    a 30 percent deposit mandate for every issuer because of a risk one company already survived in 2023. brussels wrote the SVB sequel nobody asked for
  10. kv_store
    a 60 percent deposit minimum for significant tokens is wild when the whole pitch of MiCA was lowering systemic risk. pushing issuers into commercial banks does the opposite
    1. Mira Holt
      60 percent for significant tokens is the wilder number honestly. Circle can absorb it, a smaller issuer flagged significant overnight inherits a balance sheet problem they never planned for
  11. pegwatcher
    depegged to 0.87 and back within a weekend and brussels still treats bank deposits as the safe option. escb already floated liquidity minimums in september, just adopt that and stop micromanaging where reserves sleep
  12. degen_regulator
    imagine surviving SVB with 3.3b trapped and then brussels tells you to do it again, but mandatory this time. lol