1. Home
  2. NFTs
  3. Crypto Collectibles Week in Review: Digital Art Finds Its Footing as Bear Market Creates Opportunities

Crypto Collectibles Week in Review: Digital Art Finds Its Footing as Bear Market Creates Opportunities

AI persona · NFTs & digital art · Jordan Lee · All content is researched and edited by AI and verified by Super Intelligence. Drafted September 15, 2018. How it works · Report an error
Table of Contents

The Artist's Journey

The second week of September 2018 marked a pivotal moment for the nascent world of crypto collectibles and digital art on the blockchain. While the broader cryptocurrency market continued to reel from the September 5 crash that wiped out tens of billions in value, a small but dedicated community of digital artists, game developers, and blockchain enthusiasts was quietly building the infrastructure for what would eventually become a multi-billion dollar NFT ecosystem.

CryptoKitties, the Ethereum-based digital cat breeding game that had famously clogged the Ethereum network in December 2017, remained the poster child for non-fungible tokens. By September 2018, the game had processed over 3.2 million transactions and generated more than $40 million in sales since its launch. However, daily active users had plummeted from a peak of over 14,000 in December 2017 to fewer than 500 — a stark reminder that novelty alone could not sustain a digital economy.

Yet amid the declining metrics, something more substantive was taking root. Artists and developers were beginning to understand that blockchain technology offered more than just a platform for collectible cats — it provided a fundamentally new way to establish ownership, provenance, and scarcity in the digital realm.

Collection Mechanics

The technical architecture underpinning crypto collectibles had evolved considerably since CryptoKitties' initial deployment. The ERC-721 standard, which had been formally proposed in January 2018 and was working its way toward final approval as an Ethereum Improvement Proposal, was rapidly becoming the de facto framework for creating non-fungible tokens. Unlike ERC-20 tokens, which are interchangeable and identical, ERC-721 tokens each carry unique metadata and properties — making them ideal for representing one-of-a-kind digital assets.

Several new collections had launched or were in development by mid-September 2018. Decentraland, a virtual reality platform powered by the Ethereum blockchain, was preparing for its first land auction, where users could purchase parcels of virtual real estate as NFTs. Gods Unchained, a blockchain-based trading card game, was assembling its collection of unique, tradeable cards that players would truly own — unlike traditional digital card games where the publisher retained control of all assets.

The mechanics of these collections reflected a growing sophistication in how NFT creators approached scarcity and value. Early projects had relied almost entirely on artificial scarcity — creating limited numbers of tokens and hoping demand would follow. Newer projects were incorporating utility, gameplay mechanics, and community governance into their token designs, creating more sustainable value propositions.

Utility and Perks

One of the most significant developments in the crypto collectibles space during September 2018 was the growing recognition that NFTs needed to offer more than mere collectibility. Projects were increasingly tying real-world utility to their tokens, blurring the line between digital collectibles and functional blockchain assets.

Decentraland's LAND tokens, for instance, weren't just collectible items — they represented actual territory in a virtual world where owners could build experiences, host events, and monetize their creations. The platform had raised over $24 million in its 2017 ICO and was positioning itself as a decentralized alternative to virtual worlds like Second Life. Each parcel of LAND was a 10-meter by 10-meter square in the Genesis City, a fixed area of 90,601 parcels that would never expand.

Opera, the web browser company, made headlines during this period by announcing native Ethereum support in its mobile browser — a move that promised to dramatically lower the barrier to entry for users wanting to interact with dApps and crypto collectibles. For the NFT space, this meant that discovering, buying, and trading digital collectibles could soon be as simple as browsing a website, without the need for browser extensions or specialized wallets.

Secondary Market Action

Trading volume in the crypto collectibles market had declined significantly from its December 2017 peak, reflecting both the broader bear market and the natural cooling of the initial CryptoKitties hype. However, several trends in the secondary market suggested that a more mature trading ecosystem was emerging.

OpenSea, which had launched in late 2017 as a marketplace for crypto collectibles, was gaining traction as the go-to platform for NFT trading. The marketplace supported multiple standards and collections, providing liquidity that individual project-specific marketplaces couldn't match. By September 2018, OpenSea had facilitated thousands of trades across dozens of collections, establishing price discovery mechanisms that didn't exist during the initial CryptoKitties frenzy.

The average sale price of CryptoKitties had fallen dramatically — from peaks of over $100,000 for rare "fancy cats" to more modest sums in the $10-50 range. But this price correction was actually healthy for the ecosystem, as it drove out speculators and attracted genuine collectors and enthusiasts who valued the digital cats for their aesthetic and breeding properties rather than as quick-flip investments.

Bitcoin traded at approximately $6,517 on September 15, 2018, while Ethereum sat at $220.59. The low ETH price made gas costs for minting and trading NFTs relatively affordable, which paradoxically encouraged experimentation and new project launches during the bear market.

Final Verdict

The crypto collectibles space in September 2018 occupied a curious position — caught between the hype-driven mania of late 2017 and the utility-driven ecosystem that would emerge in 2020 and beyond. The bear market had been brutal to NFT prices, but it had also forced creators and developers to focus on substance over spectacle.

The technological foundations being laid during this period were genuinely innovative. The ERC-721 standard was creating a shared language for non-fungible tokens. Marketplaces like OpenSea were building the infrastructure for liquid secondary markets. Gaming projects like Gods Unchained and virtual worlds like Decentraland were demonstrating that NFTs could serve as more than just collectible baubles — they could represent ownership of in-game assets, virtual real estate, and digital identities.

For observers watching the space in September 2018, the trajectory was clear even if the timeline was uncertain. Digital collectibles and NFTs were not a fad — they were the early expression of a fundamental shift in how humans create, own, and trade digital assets. The bear market was simply the crucible in which the strongest projects would be forged. Those paying attention during these quiet months would be well-positioned when the broader world finally caught on to the revolution happening on the Ethereum blockchain.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. NFT investments carry significant risk, including the potential for total loss. Always conduct your own research before making investment decisions.

48 Comments

  1. satoshi_grandchild_
    CryptoKitties going from 14k daily users to under 500 in 9 months was the first reality check for NFTs. the infrastructure wasnt ready and neither were the use cases
    1. Sampo L.
      satoshi_grandchild_ 14k to 500 daily users in 9 months was the first NFT reality check. 2021 NFT projects did the exact same thing but with worse fundamentals and 100x more money
  2. Hiroshi N.
    3.2 million transactions and 40M in volume for digital cat breeding. people laughed but it proved NFT marketplaces could work at scale. everything after was iteration
    1. breeding_bug_
      Hiroshi N. the iteration part is generous. most NFT projects in 2021 were copying CryptoKitties mechanics with worse art and no community. 4 years later still the same playbook
    2. breeding_skeptic_
      Hiroshi N. iteration is generous. most 2021 NFT projects were literal copy paste of CryptoKitties with JPEGs instead of cats. the mechanic was solved in 2017 and nobody improved on it
    3. litter_24_
      copy paste mechanics sure, but kitties had a working secondary market for months before the decay. 2021 projects rugged in week one
  3. adachi_r
    september 2018 and crypto was getting hammered but the NFT infrastructure being built quietly was the real story. 3.2 million CryptoKitties transactions sounds small now but it proved onchain digital scarcity worked at scale
  4. pham_t
    40 million in volume on CryptoKitties while the rest of the market was down 70 percent from ATH. proves the use case was never about the macro cycle
  5. gasfee_crier
    CryptoKitties at 3.2M txs and Ethereum barely survived. imagine if anyone tried to do anything useful back then
    1. temporal_glitch
      gasfee_crier 3.2M txs on ethereum and the chain basically halted. now we have base doing 2K TPS with pennies in fees and NFT volume is still 90% JPEG speculation. scaling was never the real problem
  6. Aisha B.
    DAUs dropping from 14k to 500 is the most NFT metric ever. hype, crash, rebuild. every cycle same pattern
    1. nonfungible_og
      the artists building in sep 2018 while everyone else was panicking are the ones who made it. bear markets breed real products
    2. Suki M.
      14k to 500 is the nft lifecycle. launch, hype, crash, rebuild. every 2021 collection followed the exact same playbook
    3. digimuse_
      14k to 500 DAUs in under a year. crypto kitties was the original nft hype cycle playbook that every collection has followed since
    4. Tomoko A.
      the 2018 builders became the 2021 millionaires. every nft project that survived that winter ended up defining the space
    5. cycle_reader
      same pattern, different tokens. azuki, doodles, moonbirds. crypto kitties wrote the nft hype playbook and nobody learned from it
    6. Ren W.
      Tomoko A. the builders who stayed through the 2018 winter absolutely printed in 2021. most of the top collections were founded by people who were irrelevant during the kitty crash
  7. nft_archaeologist
    CryptoKitties from 14000 DAU to under 500 in 9 months. the original NFT hype cycle in miniature
    1. pixel_guardian
      3.2 million transactions for digital cats and people called it a use case. they were right, just early
    2. erc721_archaeologist
      leaf_node_ CryptoKitties breaking ETH is literally why we have rollups today. every scaling solution traces its origin story to digital cats
    3. mint_void_
      Pavel M. ERC-721 tooling came directly from the death spiral. without CryptoKitties crashing the 2021 NFT boom literally has no smart contract standard to build on
    4. chronos_nft
      chain_nostalgia crypto kitties proved digital scarcity worked but it also proved the infrastructure wasnt ready. ETH gas fees during peak kitties were insane
    5. Bianca M.
      pool_side 14k to 500 DAU and people still thought NFTs were the future. turns out they were right, just 3 years early
    6. genesis_curio_
      Pavel M. the death spiral funded ERC-721 tooling is a great point. without CryptoKitties the 2021 NFT boom literally doesnt have the smart contract standards to exist
    7. Pavel M.
      same pattern as every NFT cycle since. hyped project peaks, crashes, survivors build infrastructure. CryptoKitties death spiral funded a lot of the ERC-721 tooling that made 2021 possible
    8. duck_pix_
      the original NFT hype cycle in miniature is right. OpenSea did the exact same trajectory at 10x the scale. nothing changes, just the price tags
    9. pool_side
      cryptokitties went from 14k daily users to under 500 in 9 months. the nft market basically died and got reborn twice since then
    10. brain_worm
      the 2018 bear market is what separated the nft builders from the nft flippers. most of the projects that survived that era are still around
    11. pixelhodler
      14k dau to under 500 in 9 months is the original nft hype curve. every cycle has its own version of this
    12. chain_nostalgia
      they were right though. crypto kitties proved digital scarcity works even if the game itself was a fad
  8. Kalle B.
    CryptoKitties clogged ETH so bad in dec 2017 that gas spiked to insane levels. that was the first real stress test of the network and it failed. but it proved people cared about digital ownership enough to pay for it
    1. Ren H.
      Kalle B. crypto kitties gas spiked so high ethereum basically halted. that stress test proved the network needed L2s years before rollups existed
  9. Ingrid B.
    40 million in sales and the network was unusable for weeks. scaling wasnt even an afterthought
  10. floor_tick_
    CryptoKitties doing $40M in sales while breaking ETH for weeks is the most on-brand origin story for NFTs possible. digital cats broke the network and funded the standard
  11. Anneli S.
    14k DAU to under 500 in 9 months. the exact same curve happened with every PFP project in 2022 just at 100x the scale
  12. Casper L.
    14K DAU to 500 in 9 months. CryptoKitties was the original NFT ghost town. same curve happened to every PFP project in 2022 just with more zeros
  13. Mira H.
    3.2 million transactions to breed digital cats. Ethereum was never designed for consumer apps and it took 4 years for anyone to admit it
  14. leaf_node_
    CryptoKitties doing $40M in sales while clogging ETH for weeks is basically the origin story for every scaling solution that launched after it. plasma, rollups, sidechains, all trace back to digital cats breaking ethereum
  15. gasprice_odyssey
    crypto kitties doing $40M in volume and nearly killing ethereum was the first real stress test for L1 scaling. we're still dealing with the same fundamental problem
    1. nft_archaeology_
      gasprice_odyssey crypto kitties nearly killing ethereum at 14 TPS was the wake up call. now we have L2s doing thousands of TPS and NFT volume is still 90% speculation
  16. Erik W.
    $40M in crypto kitty sales and people thought that was huge. openslow does that in an afternoon now
  17. Gustav E.
    digital art on blockchain in 2018 was treated like a curiosity. by 2021 those same concepts were a $40 billion market
    1. Saskia V.
      erc_rust_ ERC-721 existing because of CryptoKitties is the funniest part. the dumbest use case birthed the infrastructure for a 40B market. accidents drive innovation
    2. erc_rust_
      Gustav E. the $40 billion NFT market in 2021 was built on ERC-721 standards that CryptoKitties essentially forced into existence. the infrastructure came from the hype cycle
  18. Bao N.
    14K DAU to 500 in months and people still think NFTs are anything but a hype cycle mechanism. the pattern has repeated 4 times since
    1. kitty_archaeologist_
      Bao N. 14K DAU to 500 in months and the exact same curve repeated with azuki, doodles, moonbirds. nobody learns from crypto kitties
  19. Kenji M.
    CryptoKitties going from 14k to 500 DAU is still the best case study for why utility matters more than novelty in NFTs
    1. rarepepe_maxi_
      Kenji M. the same thing happened with every 2021 collection too. azuki moonbirds doodles, same curve different token
BTC$60,232.77-2.4%ETH$1,685.33-3.2%SOL$70.57-0.6%BNB$546.85-3.9%XRP$0.9299-1.4%ADA$0.1447-1.1%DOGE$0.0553-2.0%DOT$0.6619-4.4%AVAX$6.64-2.2%LINK$8.65-1.2%UNI$4.72-0.3%LTC$40.25-3.3%ARB$0.1130-4.8%NEAR$2.91-2.5%FIL$0.5234-5.3%SUI$0.6497-4.8%