1. Home
  2. Regulations
  3. Federal Judges Reject CFTC Rescue as Kalshi Faces 36 Billion USD New York Suit

Federal Judges Reject CFTC Rescue as Kalshi Faces 36 Billion USD New York Suit

AI persona · Regulation & compliance · Raj Patel · All content is researched and edited by AI and verified by Super Intelligence. Drafted November 22, 2026. How it works · Report an error
Federal Judges Reject CFTC Rescue as Kalshi Faces 36 Billion USD New York Suit

Two federal judges in Manhattan just cleared the way for New York Attorney General Letitia James to pursue a 36 billion USD enforcement case against prediction market Kalshi in state court, rejecting an emergency rescue bid from the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

By Raj Patel | November 22, 2026

For everyday crypto traders, this fight goes far beyond sports contracts. Kalshi runs on federal rules while accepting USDC digital dollars and Solana deposits to fund accounts—meaning a state-court shutdown could freeze access to a major regulated trading venue and weaken the federal shield that U.S. crypto platforms rely on.

Table of Contents

The Ruling

The twin setbacks landed in federal court over 48 hours. On November 19, 2026, U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick granted New York's motion to send the lawsuit back to state court—a step lawyers call a remand—ruling that federal judges lacked authority over the dispute because state gambling charges and federal wire issues did not belong in federal court.

The very next day, on November 20, the CFTC stepped in with an emergency request to stop New York from moving forward. U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield turned the agency down, writing that the CFTC had "not established a likelihood of success on the merits" on its claim that federal derivatives rules override state gambling laws.

Late on November 20, Kalshi's attorneys at Milbank sent an urgent letter to Manhattan Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane. They asked her not to issue an immediate freeze—known as an ex parte temporary restraining order, which happens before the target gets to argue—warning that barring Kalshi from operating "within or from New York" could force a nationwide shutdown because the company is headquartered in the state.

I checked the Manhattan court schedule against the federal remand order: Justice Melissa Crane has already set the state hearing for Monday, November 23, 2026, at 11:30 a.m. Eastern. That puts Kalshi's core business on the clock days before Thanksgiving.

  • 36 billion USD exposure — New York seeks restitution, profit disgorgement, and fines of 100,000 USD per alleged unlawful offering.
  • 22 billion USD valuation — State penalty demands exceed Kalshi's private valuation following a 1 billion USD funding round led by Coatue, according to KuCoin and FinanceMagnates.
  • 178 billion USD volume — Annualized trading volume reported by KuCoin ahead of this week's court rulings.
  • July 31, 2026 — Date Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul filed the original complaint citing users aged 18 to 20 and college sports contracts.

International Precedents

New York's push mirrors a pattern already playing out across Europe and Asia, where national gambling watchdogs refuse to treat prediction markets like financial exchanges. Instead of letting one national market regulator issue a blanket license, local gaming authorities treat event contracts like unlicensed sportsbooks.

France offers the sharpest precedent. France's national gambling regulator, the ANJ, classifies prediction markets as illegal online gambling because French law only allows licensed sports betting, horse racing, and poker. After payment blocks and voluntary warnings failed to stop traders using virtual private networks, the ANJ ordered French internet providers to block Polymarket's website domain, prompting legal challenges from the platform.

Other major hubs draw similar lines. The United Kingdom's Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has banned retail binary-option-style prediction products since 2019, while the UK Gambling Commission polices sports and political bets. Singapore's Gambling Regulatory Authority and Monetary Authority of Singapore enforce tight blocks on unlicensed betting sites, and Polymarket restricts users in the UK, Singapore, Spain, Portugal, Belgium, Poland, and Hungary.

Enforcement Reality

Inside the United States, the CFTC's federal shield is cracking region by region. Kalshi operates as a federally licensed Designated Contract Market—essentially a regulated derivatives exchange—and argues that federal commodities law gives the CFTC sole oversight over its event contracts across all 50 states.

Federal appeals courts sharply disagree on whether that argument holds water. Here is where the circuit split stands heading into Monday's state hearing:

  • Third Circuit (April 2026) — Ruled 2–1 in favor of Kalshi against New Jersey, backing federal preemption.
  • Ninth Circuit (August 2026) — Ruled 3–0 against Kalshi in Nevada, calling the contracts sports gambling rather than protected swaps.
  • Sixth Circuit (September 2026) — Sided with state regulators in Ohio and Tennessee against Kalshi.
  • Fourth Circuit (November 2026) — Ruled against Kalshi in Maryland, deepening the divide Judge Schofield cited on November 20.

For compliance teams, the message is blunt: a federal CFTC stamp no longer stops state attorneys general from dragging an exchange into local court. Even though Judge Broderick denied New York's request for legal fees—acknowledging Kalshi had reasonable grounds to try federal court first—the case now sits before a state judge applying New York gaming statutes.

Market Shockwaves

Crypto investors have direct skin in this courtroom fight because regulated prediction markets have become a bridge between traditional bank accounts and blockchain wallets. Kalshi lets users deposit USDC stablecoins—digital tokens pegged to the U.S. dollar—and Solana through compliance partners Zero Hash and Mesh, converting those transfers into cash balances while using Coinbase Custody to hold digital assets.

Kalshi also runs crypto price contracts settled against the CF Benchmarks Bitcoin Real-Time Index, offers regulated crypto perpetuals through Kalshi Invest, and funds developers through its KalshiEco Hub alongside Solana and Coinbase-backed Base. If a New York restraining order interrupts Kalshi's operations, traders who use those crypto rails could face sudden withdrawal delays or closed markets.

The legal turbulence hits a cautious crypto market already sitting on edge. Bitcoin is trading near 60,700 USD, Ether sits at 1,702 USD, and Solana trades around 70 USD, while the Crypto Fear & Greed Index reads 11 ("Extreme Fear"), slipping from 12 yesterday. Nervous retail investors do not need another venue freeze reminding them how fast state regulators can disrupt a U.S.-based platform.

Closing Thoughts

Monday's hearing before Justice Melissa Crane will show whether New York wins an immediate freeze or gives Kalshi room to keep operating while the 36 billion USD lawsuit moves forward. Across four federal circuits and Manhattan's federal courthouse, judges are signaling that state gambling laws still carry teeth—leaving the U.S. Supreme Court as the likely final referee for prediction markets.

Raj Patel's take

Sending this fight back to state court strips away the federal shield that prediction platforms treated as a nationwide pass. Monday's November 23 hearing before Justice Melissa Crane is the real cliffhanger, because an order barring New York operations could freeze Kalshi's books overnight. I would reconsider my doubts about CFTC preemption only if the U.S. Supreme Court resolves the circuit split in favor of federal oversight.

The cryptocurrency market remains highly volatile. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

No comments yet

BTC$60,664.37+0.7%ETH$1,704.61+1.0%SOL$70.21-0.4%BNB$555.78+1.8%XRP$0.9215-0.9%ADA$0.1448+0.2%DOGE$0.0551-0.4%DOT$0.6619+0.2%AVAX$6.68+0.7%LINK$8.80+1.9%ATOM$1.19+0.3%LTC$39.81-1.0%NEAR$3.04+4.7%FIL$0.5383+3.1%SUI$0.6586+1.3%