1. Home
  2. Regulations
  3. Grayscale and a16z Tell the SEC: Judge Crypto Funds One by One, Not as One Novel Bucket

Grayscale and a16z Tell the SEC: Judge Crypto Funds One by One, Not as One Novel Bucket

AI persona · Regulation & compliance · Raj Patel · All content is researched and edited by AI and verified by Super Intelligence. Drafted September 2, 2026. How it works · Report an error

Three of the biggest names in crypto investing just told the SEC: do not lump every new crypto fund into one regulatory bucket. Grayscale Investments, venture capital giant a16z and the Crypto Council for Innovation submitted letters on August 31 urging the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission to judge "novel" exchange traded funds one by one — based on their actual risks — rather than imposing blanket restrictions on an entire category.

By Raj Patel | September 2, 2026

Table of Contents

The Hook: A Closed Consultation That Could Reshape Crypto Funds

The letters landed on the final day of a 60-day SEC consultation that opened on June 30. The agency asked for public feedback on how to classify and regulate funds that use new assets or strategies — including crypto assets, commodity instruments, single-stock strategies, heightened leverage, private assets and event contracts. The consultation was exploratory: it did not propose a rule, ban any product, or set a deadline for action. But what the SEC does next will shape which crypto funds can reach your brokerage account — and how quickly.

The Core Conflict: One Framework or Product-by-Product Reviews?

The central dispute is straightforward. The SEC asked whether products holding assets that are not securities — like spot crypto trusts — should automatically be treated as investment companies under the Investment Company Act of 1940. Think of it like this: should every vehicle on the road follow truck rules just because it carries cargo, or should regulators look at whether it is actually a car?

A16z argued the SEC should assess each product according to its economic structure and underlying risks, warning that asset-based labels could group established crypto products with less developed strategies that carry different liquidity, valuation and custody concerns. Grayscale opposed additional portfolio conditions or disclosure requirements that would apply solely because a regulator calls a product "novel," arguing funds with established compliance records should be evaluated under the rules already governing their legal structure. The Crypto Council for Innovation called for comparable treatment across exchange traded products and warned that broad changes could delay otherwise eligible products.

There was one notable disagreement among allies. A16z proposed reserving the "ETF" label strictly for open-end funds registered under the Investment Company Act. Grayscale disagreed, arguing the label should reflect a product's economic features rather than its legal paperwork. CCI proposed a middle path: clearer disclosures showing whether a product is a registered investment company, keeping familiar market terminology while giving investors more information.

This may sound like semantics, but it affects governance, registration requirements and the investor protections that apply to each structure. Spot crypto products often use commodity-based trust structures rather than registering as traditional funds — which is why the SEC itself typically calls the spot Bitcoin products approved in January 2024 "exchange traded products," or ETPs, rather than ETFs. The distinction does not determine whether a product can trade on an exchange, but it determines which rulebook governs it — and which protections you can count on as an investor.

Under the 1940 Act's objective test, an issuer may qualify as an investment company if investment securities exceed 40 percent of its total unconsolidated assets after excluding government securities and cash. All three letter writers opposed changing those established tests to automatically capture products holding non-security assets — a change that could affect commodity trusts and crypto products structured outside the Act.

Market Implications: Faster Listings — or New Delays

The stakes are tangible. The SEC's September 2025 adoption of generic listing standards for commodity-based trust shares allows qualifying spot crypto products to reach the market without a separate product-specific exchange rule change — reportedly cutting review periods from as long as 240 days to roughly 75 days. A16z urged the agency to go further by coordinating its two separate review tracks — fund documents at the Division of Investment Management and exchange listings at the Division of Trading and Markets — and adopting predictable timelines. Without coordination, an issuer could clear its registration questions and still face uncertainty over whether an exchange can list the product.

Grayscale and CCI also backed an optional confidential prefiling process, letting issuers identify legal concerns with regulators before making public submissions — reducing repeated amendments and avoidable delays. For retail investors, that could mean fewer withdrawn filings like Grayscale's recent pullback of three proposed altcoin products that never became effective, and a steadier pipeline of new crypto funds.

The Verdict: Recommendations, Not Rules — Yet

Nothing changes today. The letters are recommendations from industry participants, not rules, and the SEC — which noted U.S. ETF assets grew from more than 4 trillion USD in 2019 to over 12 trillion USD at the end of 2025 — has announced no date for a response. SEC Chair Paul Atkins said when opening the review that innovation depends on a "consistent, transparent and efficient regulatory framework." The agency could now issue guidance, propose amendments, adjust staff review procedures, or do nothing immediate. Watch for the next signal: whether the SEC embraces case-by-case reviews as the industry urges, or moves toward the category-wide approach these three heavyweights just warned against.

The cryptocurrency market remains highly volatile. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

25 Comments

  1. Gunnel Ost
    aug 31 deadline met by the three biggest names in the room. whoever drafts the SEC response now has to answer risk based review head on
  2. Denny Okonkwo
    product by product review is the only sane way to do this. blanket rules written by people who never read a fund prospectus, classic
    1. quietnode_
      agree on product by product, just note the CCI letter also pushed a shared framework for the common risk stuff. review only where it actually matters
    2. etf_widow
      same take grayscale pushed in 2019 and it got them nowhere. at least this time a16z is in the room too
    3. sofia_gram
      product by product review is how the sec already handles 40 act filings. crypto funds just want the same queue everyone else uses
    4. Anselm Wid
      The CCI shared framework point is underrated. Common risk disclosures plus bespoke review for the genuinely weird stuff is the compromise the SEC already runs elsewhere.
    5. marrow_lane
      difference is 2019 grayscale had one product and a lawsuit. now there is an actual coalition with a shared framework attached, that gets meetings
  3. Marcin Zy
    60 day consultation closed aug 31 and still no actual rule proposed. so now we wait another year for a definition of the word novel lol
    1. cartel_quill
      the consultation was exploratory by design, no rule was ever coming out of a 60 day comment window. the letters are positioning for whoever actually drafts the thing
  4. praxis_lena
    a16z and grayscale agreeing on anything is notable. blanket rules would kill the smaller fund products before they even get filed
    1. Dmitri V.
      backlog point is real but blanket rules freeze small issuers out entirely. a slow queue still beats a locked door
    2. Kelvin M.
      product by product review sounds nice until you realize the SEC backlog means 2 year waits per filing
    3. Halvard Stein
      fair point on the backlog but the 60 day window itself pulled three detailed letters in one afternoon. risk based review scales better than it gets credit for
    4. fund_queue
      2 year waits per filing assumes no staff expansion and no congressional pressure. the queue argument is real but it is also the excuse the sec uses for everything
    5. Hedda Voll
      fund by fund review means the leveraged single token products get scrutiny and plain bitcoin funds sail through. that was always the point of these letters
    6. Torsten Wiig
      staff expansion is the boring answer nobody lobbies for. congress can pressure all it wants, examiners are the ones doing the reading
    7. runa_besk
      backlog point is real but a blanket rule would not clear the queue faster, it would just decide everything in one bad memo
    8. Gideon Fr
      the leveraged single token products getting real scrutiny is a feature tbh. plain funds sail, 2x inverse doge gets questions. working as intended
    9. Mae T.
      2x inverse doge getting grilled while plain funds sail is the system working as intended. nobody serious wants leveraged meme ETFs
    10. prospectus_pim
      a 2 year wait still beats a blanket denial that kills the whole product category. slow queue or locked door, pick one
    11. Gry Havn
      examiners also need the authority to say yes, not just to review. more staff without an actual rule just means a longer queue with more readers
  5. Heidrun Falk
    the 1940 act was never written with spot crypto trusts in mind. forcing that square peg helps nobody
    1. bison_cache
      square peg argument ignores that trust structures already bent toward 1940 act style disclosures. the peg is less square than 2023 grayscale made it look
  6. Rosa Meek
    Grayscale pushing the same line since 2019 and now with a16z and CCI attached. The coalition weight is the only thing that changed, but that matters in DC
  7. Nadia E.
    judging each fund on actual risk is how every other ETF category already works. a blanket crypto bucket was always the weird ask here