1. Home
  2. Regulations
  3. Judge Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers in 25 Million USD Ethereum Bot Case

Judge Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers in 25 Million USD Ethereum Bot Case

AI persona · Regulation & compliance · Raj Patel · All content is researched and edited by AI and verified by Super Intelligence. Drafted November 17, 2026. How it works · Report an error

On November 16, 2026, U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan acquitted brothers Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno of all federal charges tied to a 25 million USD Ethereum exploit, handing the Justice Department a major courtroom defeat. For everyday crypto investors, the ruling shows that federal wire fraud laws will not automatically punish aggressive on-chain trading tactics—leaving users on decentralized apps to rely on better software protections rather than criminal prosecutors to keep automated bots in check.

By Raj Patel | November 17, 2026

Table of Contents

The Ruling

The decision ends a closely watched criminal prosecution in Case No. 1:24-cr-00293 without a second trial. Back in April 2023, the MIT-educated brothers carried out a 12-second trading sequence dubbed "Omakase" that pulled roughly 25 million USD from automated "sandwich bots" operating on the Ethereum blockchain.

Think of sandwich bots like computerized ticket scalpers watching a public checkout line. When an everyday trader submits a swap on a decentralized exchange—an app that lets people trade directly from their digital wallets without a company in the middle—a sandwich bot spots that pending order, cuts in front to buy first, and sells back moments later at a higher price. In this case, the brothers planted bait transactions and exploited a flaw in MEV-Boost, a software tool used by Ethereum's digital bookkeepers to order incoming trades, trapping the bots with nearly worthless tokens instead.

Federal prosecutors arrested and indicted the brothers in May 2024 on three counts: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. After a multi-week trial in November 2025 ended in a mistrial because the jury could not agree on a verdict, Judge Clarke granted the defense's Rule 29 motion—a legal step where a judge throws out charges outright when the government's trial evidence falls short of the law's requirements.

  • 25 million USD drained in 12 seconds — Targeted automated Ethereum sandwich bots via an April 2023 MEV-Boost software flaw.
  • All three federal counts dismissed — Because wire fraud failed, the related fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy charges collapsed too.
  • Permanent acquittal without retrial — Judge Clarke's Rule 29 order on November 16, 2026, closes the criminal case for good.
  • No false statements proved — Prosecutors failed to show the brothers told an actionable lie under federal wire fraud law.

In her written opinion, Judge Clarke separated moral judgment from statutory law. "The question before the Court is not whether the Peraire-Buenos' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes," she wrote. "It is simply whether the evidence at trial, construed in a light most favorable to the Government, could support wire fraud and related convictions in this case." Calling Ethereum a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use," she concluded that outmaneuvering trading bots "frustrated the spirit" of the software without proving any "material misrepresentations"—the deliberate lies required for wire fraud. Defense attorney Daniel Marx of Fick & Marx said the case rested on "fundamental misunderstandings about decentralized financial networks," adding that the brothers "never lied to anyone about their trading activity," while Katherine Trefz of Williams & Connolly called the outcome "just and correct."

International Precedents

The Manhattan acquittal highlights a sharp gap between American courtrooms and overseas rulebooks. While U.S. prosecutors relied on a general fraud statute built around deception, European and British regulators have spent the past two years writing explicit rules targeting the exact mechanics of Maximal Extractable Value (MEV)—the profit earned by reordering transactions inside a blockchain block.

In the European Union, the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation moved past its final national grace period on July 1, 2026. Under MiCA's technical standards drafted by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), manipulative MEV tactics such as frontrunning and sandwich attacks involving tokens listed on regulated venues count as illegal market manipulation. Licensed European crypto platforms must actively monitor order flow and file Suspicious Transaction and Order Reports (STORs) when they spot abusive bot behavior, and European authorities have pushed to hold app interfaces accountable as gatekeepers when they route customer trades into predatory pools.

The United Kingdom has taken a similarly direct path. Through consultation papers including CP26/36 on regulatory perimeter rules and GC26/7 on decentralized finance resilience, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has warned that calling an app "decentralized" creates no legal shield if identifiable people control the software or run a commercial service. Ahead of full UK enforcement on October 25, 2027, British regulators expect licensed firms to manage smart contract risks and structural market manipulation—responsibilities set out in black-and-white regulatory text rather than tested piecemeal through criminal indictments.

Enforcement Reality

On the U.S. side, this acquittal fits a growing pattern of federal judges rejecting stretched criminal fraud theories in open-blockchain disputes. I checked Judge Clarke's November 16, 2026, ruling alongside U.S. District Judge Arun Subramanian's May 23, 2025, decision in United States v. Eisenberg: both Manhattan judges threw out federal wire fraud theories for the exact same reason—prosecutors failed to prove a false statement.

In that earlier benchmark case, trader Avraham "Avi" Eisenberg drained roughly 110 million USD in October 2022 from Mango Markets, a decentralized lending and trading app on Solana, by pushing up the price of its token and borrowing against the inflated collateral. A Manhattan jury convicted him on April 18, 2024, of commodities fraud, commodities manipulation, and wire fraud. Yet on May 23, 2025, Judge Subramanian wiped out every count, tossing wire fraud for lack of an explicit false statement and dismissing the commodities counts because Eisenberg traded from Puerto Rico rather than New York. Prosecutors appealed on July 23, 2025, to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit under Docket No. 25-1782, where briefing carried into 2026.

Meanwhile, broad crypto market-structure legislation in Congress—including the CLARITY Act—remains stalled. Without a clear federal statute defining on-chain market abuse, regulators at the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) have leaned on agency guidance such as their March 2026 joint token taxonomy and the SEC's proposed Regulation Crypto Assets, leaving criminal prosecutors with older statutes that struggle whenever software code acts as the only referee.

Market Shockwaves

For everyday crypto holders watching prices wobble—with Ethereum (ETH) trading at 1,822 USD, Bitcoin (BTC) at 65,027 USD, and the Crypto Fear & Greed Index sitting at 12 (Extreme Fear)—the ruling sends a practical warning rather than a free pass for bad actors. Stealing private wallet keys, running fake investment websites, or lying to investors remains straightforward criminal fraud that law enforcement actively prosecutes.

What changes is the expectation around decentralized trading apps. Judge Clarke's order tells retail investors that when automated programs battle each other inside open blockchain plumbing without user agreements or false promises, federal courts may treat those losses as market casualties rather than crimes. Everyday traders who want protection from sandwich bots—and the hidden price slippage they cause—cannot count on retroactive courtroom rescues. Instead, using wallets and exchanges with built-in frontrunning protection, which route orders privately until they settle, remains the main line of defense for ordinary portfolios.

Closing Thoughts

Judge Clarke's November 16, 2026, acquittal closes the federal criminal case against Anton and James Peraire-Bueno and draws a firm legal line around open-protocol MEV trading in the United States. Until Congress enacts dedicated digital-asset market-abuse rules or the Second Circuit decides the government's appeal in United States v. Eisenberg, prosecutors face a high bar proving wire fraud where code runs without user terms or explicit falsehoods.

Raj Patel's take

Two straight Manhattan acquittals prove to me that old wire-fraud laws cannot police automated blockchain trading without stretching legal definitions past breaking point. What matters next is how the Second Circuit resolves the government's appeal in United States v. Eisenberg, docket 25-1782, where prosecutors face the exact same falsity test. I would revise my skepticism about courtroom deterrence if appellate judges reinstate that 110 million USD verdict or Congress writes explicit on-chain manipulation bans.

The cryptocurrency market remains highly volatile. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

3 Comments

  1. 0xrelayermo
    12 seconds, 25M off the sandwich bots, full acquittal. judge basically said the bots had it coming lmao
    1. Ines Kova
      She wrote that the trick frustrated the spirit of MEV-Boost without any material misrepresentation. Wire fraud needs an actual lie, that is the whole statute.
  2. subgraphvic
    Same falsity bar that wiped the Eisenberg conviction in May 2025. Two Manhattan judges, same reading. DOJ keeps bringing wire fraud against code and losing