- Home
- Regulations
- New York Sues Polymarket Over Unlicensed Gambling as Prediction Market Crackdown Widens
New York Sues Polymarket Over Unlicensed Gambling as Prediction Market Crackdown Widens

New York Attorney General Letitia James has sued Polymarket, alleging that the prediction market operated without a state gambling license and allowed users as young as 18 onto its platform. The petition, filed in a Manhattan state court on Sep. 24, puts the company in the same state legal fight as Kalshi, Coinbase Financial Markets and Gemini Titan.
Table of Contents
What New York is asking for
The state's petition argues that Polymarket offered New Yorkers contracts tied to the outcomes of future events without obtaining a license from the New York State Gaming Commission. New York is asking the court to halt the alleged unlicensed operation, order restitution for customers, impose civil fines, and require Polymarket to give up gains it says were earned illegally.
The filing cites contracts tied to sports outcomes, including a July baseball game between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the New York Mets. In the state's view, customers risk money on events they cannot control in exchange for a payout if their chosen outcome occurs, which James describes as gambling. Polymarket can contest that characterization in court.
State officials also object to Polymarket allowing users aged 18 to 20 onto the platform. New York sets a minimum age of 21 for mobile sports betting, and the attorney general argues that operating outside the state's licensing system leaves customers without the safeguards required of approved betting companies, including protections aimed at problem gambling.
Governor Kathy Hochul said the alleged operation had put New Yorkers at risk, particularly younger users whom she described as more vulnerable to gambling harm. Polymarket expressed disappointment with the lawsuit and said it would speak with the state, according to Reuters.
A pattern of cases against prediction markets
The Polymarket filing is the fourth such action from New York. James brought a case against Kalshi in July, after filing petitions against Coinbase and Gemini in April. Each case centers on the same claim: that the companies offered gambling products without the licenses required under state law. The Kalshi case also raised the age of users and the absence of state approval.
Kalshi has argued that its federal registration places its contracts under Commodity Futures Trading Commission oversight, a defense Polymarket may echo given its own CFTC-regulated market operator status. In August, the New York City Council separately examined prediction market advertising by Polymarket, Kalshi, Coinbase and Gemini Titan, an inquiry focused on allegations of deceptive marketing and possible consumer protection measures. That city review is separate from the state gambling cases.
The CFTC question at the center
The core legal dispute is whether federal oversight of event contracts prevents states from applying their gambling laws to sports-related markets. Prediction market operators argue in litigation that contracts traded on federally regulated exchanges fall under the Commodity Exchange Act and the CFTC's authority. State officials respond that a federal derivatives framework does not remove their power to license and regulate sports wagering within their borders.
James set out New York's position in April, when she joined 37 other attorneys general in a filing supporting Massachusetts's case against Kalshi. The coalition argued that Congress did not give the CFTC exclusive control over sports gambling when it expanded federal regulation of swaps through the Dodd-Frank Act. The attorneys general added that state rules address matters such as minimum betting ages and protections for people at risk of gambling harm, areas where federal derivatives law is largely silent.
Conflicting federal appeals court rulings have left the reach of state gambling laws unresolved, which is why similar cases are converging in courts across the country. A ruling against the operators would force changes to how sports-linked contracts are offered in states that choose to regulate them as gambling; a ruling for the operators would preserve the current federally regulated model.
What it means for Polymarket
Polymarket has spent the past year building out regulated United States operations, including its CFTC-licensed QCX exchange, while fighting state-level challenges. The New York suit adds the country's fourth-largest state to that list and brings restitution and forfeiture demands that go beyond injunctions. The company also faces a separate reported inquiry involving alleged stolen-card deposits, making the legal calendar busier even as trading volumes grow.
For users in New York, the immediate question is access. Similar petitions against Kalshi and Coinbase sought to restrict state residents from sports-related markets while litigation proceeds. How quickly that happens here depends on the court's response to any request for interim relief from the attorney general's office.
Market snapshot (Sep 24, ~18:50 UTC): BTC 84,354 USD, ETH 2,685.80 USD, SOL 117.10 USD — CoinGecko via BitcoinsNews price cache.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.
27 Comments