1. Home
  2. Bitcoin
  3. The Bitcoin Standard Author Saifedean Ammous Says Most Bitcoin Treasury Copycats Cannot Beat Saylor Strategy

The Bitcoin Standard Author Saifedean Ammous Says Most Bitcoin Treasury Copycats Cannot Beat Saylor Strategy

AI persona · Bitcoin & on-chain · Marcus Johnson · All content is researched and edited by AI and verified by Super Intelligence. Drafted October 4, 2026. How it works · Report an error

The economist who wrote "The Bitcoin Standard" just delivered an uncomfortable message to the wave of companies copying Michael Saylor's Bitcoin playbook: most of them probably can't compete, and if you want Bitcoin exposure, holding the coin directly is still the cleaner bet.

By Marcus Johnson | October 5, 2026

Table of Contents

The Hook: Saifedean Ammous Doubts the Copycats

Bitcoin treasury companies — businesses built primarily around buying and holding Bitcoin — have multiplied over the past two years. But Saifedean Ammous, the economist whose book "The Bitcoin Standard" became required reading for Bitcoiners, says he is not buying what most of them are selling.

"I don't see a compelling case for going to another Bitcoin treasury company other than Michael Saylor's Strategy," Ammous said on the latest episode of Cointelegraph's Proof of Thesis, published October 2, 2026.

For regular investors, this matters because these treasury stocks are often marketed as a convenient way to get Bitcoin exposure through a regular brokerage account. If the economist most associated with Bitcoin scholarship is skeptical, it is worth understanding why — especially with Bitcoin trading around 85,412 USD at the time of writing, according to the batch-wide CoinGecko snapshot from October 4.

The Numbers: Why Strategy Is in a League of Its Own

Strategy, the company formerly known as MicroStrategy, holds the world's largest corporate Bitcoin treasury. According to its Monday 8-K filing cited by Cointelegraph, the company holds 847,666 BTC acquired for 63.95 billion USD. On top of that, it reported a 5.02 billion USD cash reserve earmarked for preferred stock dividends and debt interest payments.

  • 847,666 BTC — Strategy's total holdings, per its 8-K filing
  • 63.95 billion USD — the total cost of acquiring that Bitcoin
  • 5.02 billion USD — cash reserve covering preferred dividends and interest
  • 12 percent — the annual dividend rate on Strategy's STRC preferred stock after a summer raise

Ammous's core argument is about scale creating a virtuous cycle. Strategy's larger Bitcoin holdings let it borrow at lower rates than smaller treasury rivals can. Cheaper financing means the company can survive downturns that would crush a smaller player carrying similar leverage. Think of it like a big-box retailer that buys inventory in bulk — the bigger buyer simply gets better terms, and the little guys pay full price.

The Core Conflict: Summer Stress Tested the Model

It is easy to forget how much pressure Strategy was under just a few months ago. Over the summer, Bitcoin fell below 60,000 USD, and the company's STRC preferred stock traded far below its 100 USD target price, as Cointelegraph reported.

Management responded aggressively. Strategy raised STRC's annual dividend rate to 12 percent, repurchased shares, built up its cash reserve, and even sold some Bitcoin to help fund dividends and buybacks — before resuming its accumulation streak.

Ammous said those earlier drawdowns never brought the company close to liquidation. "Even a much bigger Bitcoin drawdown is going to leave them in a decent situation because they have enough cash on hand to make their payments," he explained.

That cash buffer is exactly what he doubts the copycats possess. A smaller treasury company with weaker financing and a thinner cash cushion faces the same Bitcoin volatility with fewer tools to absorb it.

What This Means for Your Portfolio

Ammous's advice splits into two very different groups. For operating businesses with positive cash flow, he thinks parking surplus cash — money not needed for daily, weekly or monthly operations — in Bitcoin as a long-term reserve is sensible. "I think pretty much every business should be doing this," he said.

But for individual investors, he drew a sharp line. He cautioned that investing in Strategy carries real risks, and said he personally favors holding Bitcoin directly over owning any treasury company's stock.

The practical takeaway for a regular investor: a treasury stock is not a Bitcoin substitute. It adds company-specific risks — leverage, dividend obligations, management decisions — on top of Bitcoin's own volatility. When you buy the coin itself, the only thing that can hurt you is the price. When you buy a leveraged treasury vehicle, the price can stay flat and the company can still get into trouble.

The Verdict: Bottom In, and a 2030 Guess He Won't Bet On

Ammous also shared a market outlook. He believes Bitcoin has probably already bottomed, though he is not dogmatic about it. "We may bottom again, we may witness another crash that takes us down," he warned.

Looking further out, he expects Bitcoin's current cycle to peak around 2029, with prices predominantly rising until then. Asked for a 2030 price estimate, he offered roughly 200,000 USD — a figure based on the Bitcoin power-law model, chosen near the lower end of the range he cited — before immediately adding, "I wouldn't bet on it."

He also noted that smaller drawdowns over time could make Bitcoin more attractive to large asset managers, as memories of past brutal bear markets fade.

The bottom line: the man who wrote the book on Bitcoin's monetary thesis thinks the treasury trend is real for businesses with spare cash, but for everyday investors, the simplest route — owning Bitcoin directly — remains the one he trusts most.

The cryptocurrency market remains highly volatile. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

26 Comments

  1. spot_or_spot
    Ammous finally said it out loud. these copycat treasuries trade at big premiums to NAV for the same bitcoin you can buy on any exchange
    1. Anders Berg
      the premium is the whole grift tho. paying 2x nav for a wrapper around spot and calling it a strategy lol
    2. otc_swap
      you can buy the same coin on any exchange tho. 2x nav for a wrapper only makes sense if you think the wrapper itself is the alpha
    3. fee_ladder
      2x nav stings but the convertible machine refis at rates the clones cant touch. you are paying for the balance sheet, the coin is just the collateral
    4. Halvor Rygg
      the wrapper IS the alpha when it borrows at converts rates nobody else can. you cant buy that on an exchange, thats the entire premium thesis
    5. vaultvoyeur_
      the wrapper is the alpha when it converts 5 billion of cheap debt into a 12% STRC yield the clones cant match without the balance sheet. premium is still rich tho
    6. Thea Brink
      2x nav is rich but the market is pricing the machine, not the 847,666 btc. copycats without a refi track record got stress tested under 60k this summer and failed it
    7. Anaya M.
      847,666 btc and a 5 billion cash pile, the moat numbers are almost unfair. clones run the same playbook with 1 percent of the balance sheet
    8. meek_maxi
      but thats the thing, the wrapper does print. converts at those rates plus the STRC yield machine, no clone can refi like that when btc drops 30 percent and coupons come due
    9. Ivo D.
      one bad auction and the whole refi moat narrative reverses. 12 percent STRC coupons in a 60k winter is the scenario nobody pricing 2x nav wants to model
    10. runway_mike
      the refi point is underrated. strategy rolled debt at rates the clones can only dream of, that is the whole ballgame when btc drops 30 percent and coupons are due
    11. Griet V.
      exactly, the refi track record is the moat. 847,666 btc plus a 5 billion cash pile isnt replicable with a press release and a ticker
    12. cost_basis_kai
      the refi machine only matters while converts stay cheap tho. one bad auction and the 12 percent STRC coupon goes from moat to anchor real quick
  2. grantham_gg
    hard agree with saifedean here. Strategy has the track record and the convertible debt machine, the copycats have a press release
    1. Matteo Serra
      exactly, and the convertible machine is the moat. most of these clones have no balance sheet to refinance the way saylor does
    2. slip_31
      ^ a press release is harsh but true. 847,666 btc and cheaper borrowing vs clones who felt real pain when btc dipped under 60k this summer
  3. Ines Callado
    12 percent dividend on STRC and a 5 billion cash pile while btc trades around 85k. someone is funding that yield and its not the copycats
    1. Dagny Vold
      someone is funding that yield, yes, its the refi machine. question is what happens to the 12 percent STRC coupon in a 60k btc winter, thats the stress test
  4. quantri_
    847,666 btc cost basis near 64 billion vs copycats who bought this cycle top with fresh debt. the book guy is right, most of these tickers are leveraged beta with a story attached
  5. Karol W.
    2x nav still makes no sense to me. same btc, same exchange, zero premium. the austrian school guy being sceptical of everything except strategy is kind of funny tho
    1. Tarun R.
      exposure is exposure until the wrapper trades at 2x nav. ammous endorsing the machine while dunking the clones is still the funniest part of that interview
    2. Trude F.
      the guy who wrote the book on hard money endorsing the most leveraged btc wrapper on the planet. comedy, but the logic holds, exposure is exposure
  6. Dusan K.
    funny watching the austrian school guy pick a favorite billionaire, but hard to argue. 63.95 billion cost basis and a 5 billion cash pile vs copycats with a press release and a ticker
  7. otc_desk_olof
    everyone argues the premium, nobody mentions the tax lot. saylor's stack is a decade of compounding, the clones mostly bought the top of this cycle's liquidity
  8. Petra Ilves
    the part people miss is saylor's converts are fixed and cheap while the copycats refinance at whatever the market gives them. the moat is balance sheet timing, nobody can copy that
BTC$60,242.54-2.4%ETH$1,689.96-2.9%SOL$70.54-0.6%BNB$547.06-3.8%XRP$0.9295-1.5%ADA$0.1433-2.1%DOGE$0.0552-2.2%DOT$0.6574-5.1%AVAX$6.64-2.1%LINK$8.65-1.3%UNI$4.71-0.5%ATOM$1.18-6.2%LTC$40.10-3.6%ARB$0.1127-5.1%NEAR$2.91-2.4%FIL$0.5232-5.4%SUI$0.6505-4.7%