- Home
- Regulations
- CFTC Updates Crypto FAQ: What Tokenized Customer Funds and 20 Percent Haircuts Mean for Derivatives Margin
CFTC Updates Crypto FAQ: What Tokenized Customer Funds and 20 Percent Haircuts Mean for Derivatives Margin

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has updated its crypto activity FAQs, addressing two subjects that sit at the center of the tokenized-collateral debate: investments of customer funds in tokenized forms of permitted investments, and the use of blockchain technology to satisfy recordkeeping requirements. The September 24 release, numbered 9303-26, has been framed in some coverage as a new collateral rule. The documents themselves tell a narrower story, and the difference matters for any futures intermediary weighing how, and whether, to accept crypto as margin.
Table of Contents
What the update actually covers
Release 9303-26 names the Market Participants Division, the Division of Market Oversight and the Division of Clearing and Risk as the staff groups publishing the update. It specifies two matters: tokenized versions of investments already permitted for customer funds, and blockchain-based recordkeeping. It traces the FAQ series to March 20, 2026, and points back to Staff Letter 25-39 on tokenized collateral and Staff Letter 26-05 on digital assets accepted as customer margin.
The chronology is the first check on claims circulating about a new collateral permission. The collateral rules, and their conditions, predate the new release. February's Staff Letter 26-05 lets qualifying futures commission merchants, or FCMs, count certain customer crypto as margin under specified conditions, and it requires at least a 20 percent haircut for most non-stablecoin crypto in specified intermediary calculations.
The original March FAQs also drew a line that survives into the September update: an FCM may not invest customer funds in payment stablecoins under Regulation 1.25 merely because it can accept a qualifying stablecoin as customer margin. An FCM may place its own payment stablecoins into segregated customer accounts as residual interest under the staff letter. Those are different sources of funds and different transactions. A tokenized form of an investment already permitted under Regulation 1.25 is a question about the wrapper on an eligible underlying asset, not a general license for an intermediary to use customer cash to buy bitcoin or a payment stablecoin.
Whose asset, which haircut, who fills the shortfall
The regulatory papers separate movements that a falling market joins together. Staff Letter 26-05 concerns what an FCM may count while evaluating a customer account and segregated funds. A derivatives clearing organization, or DCO, sets its own haircut for assets accepted as initial margin under separate rules, with discretion subject to at least monthly review. A 20 percent charge on an intermediary's proprietary bitcoin inventory is a third, distinct issue. Applying one number to all three produces a false answer.
A deliberately simple illustration shows the mechanics. A customer posts bitcoin worth 100,000 USD, and the relevant FCM calculation applies a 20 percent haircut. Recognized value is 80,000 USD. If bitcoin's spot value then falls 15 percent to 85,000 USD and the haircut remains 20 percent, recognized value becomes 68,000 USD. The haircut did not change; the market fell. The account has lost 12,000 USD of recognized collateral value without a single coin leaving custody.
Now assume the margin requirement for the futures position stays at 75,000 USD. Before the move, recognized collateral exceeded the requirement by 5,000 USD. After the move, 68,000 USD leaves a 7,000 USD shortfall. If the position itself simultaneously loses 10,000 USD, the economic pressure compounds, though the precise cash call depends on the account's other balances, settlement, portfolio margin and the FCM's rules.
It follows that a 20 percent haircut is not an insurance policy against a 20 percent fall. Starting from 100,000 USD, a 25 percent spot drop leaves the asset worth 75,000 USD and its post-haircut value at 60,000 USD, a 20,000 USD decline in recognized credit from a move the haircut was often assumed to absorb.
A no-action letter, not a rule change
Staff Letter 26-05 is a no-action position: the Market Participants Division says it will not recommend enforcement against an FCM acting within specified conditions. It does not repeal the customer segregation provisions of the Commodity Exchange Act, and it does not promise that a DCO will accept every coin. The letter was originally issued following a request by Coinbase Financial Markets and was reissued on February 6, 2026, to clarify that a national trust bank may qualify as a payment stablecoin issuer for its purposes.
A clearinghouse still has to decide whether a proposed collateral asset carries sufficiently low credit, market and liquidity risk for its clearing program. Chairman Michael Selig has discussed round-the-clock markets and tokenized collateral publicly, and the agency sent a broader crypto market rulemaking, titled "Regulation Crypto Asset Transactions and Regulation Crypto Asset Markets," to the White House for review on September 17, two days after the Senate's CLARITY Act cloture failure. An agency's interest in those markets does not eliminate the ordinary margin test.
Why the FAQ update arrives now
The practical question has become more urgent as firms put digital assets into structures usually associated with cash and government securities. The September update addresses the recordkeeping and permitted-investment questions that follow: if a permitted Treasury fund exists in tokenized form, what does an FCM need to know before holding it, and when does a blockchain record satisfy Commission rules written for paper ledgers. The release supports only its stated scope, and market participants would be well advised not to attribute new haircut values or eligibility categories to it ahead of the full FAQ text.
Bitcoin trades near 83,714 USD, Ethereum near 2,686.80 USD and Solana near 119.70 USD as of the 14:46 UTC price snapshot on September 25, 2026.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.
25 Comments