- Home
- Regulations
- Chainalysis Beats 15 Celsius Claims but Judge Keeps the 3.3 Billion USD Audit Case Alive
Chainalysis Beats 15 Celsius Claims but Judge Keeps the 3.3 Billion USD Audit Case Alive

Chainalysis has knocked out most of the lawsuit brought by Celsius Network's litigation administrator, but a U.S. federal judge has refused to dismiss the heart of the case: claims that the blockchain analytics firm helped the collapsed lender market a disputed 3.3 billion USD "audit" of its assets in 2020.
Table of Contents
What survived, what died
Judge Margaret Garnett of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York ruled on Sept. 29 that Count One of the complaint — an aiding-and-abetting claim tied to alleged breaches of fiduciary duty by Celsius insiders — was sufficiently pleaded and can proceed. At the same time, the court dismissed 15 consumer-protection claims against Chainalysis, twelve of them with prejudice, meaning they cannot be refiled in their current form. Three others were dismissed without prejudice and can be amended by Oct. 20.
The surviving claim is pursued by the Blockchain Recovery Investment Consortium, which acts as litigation administrator for the estate of the collapsed lender. The court found the complaint adequately alleged that Chainalysis knew a December 2020 press release contained false statements about Celsius's assets under management and actively participated in spreading them — including allegations that the company helped draft the release and approved the word "audit" five times, despite knowing the underlying calculation was neither an audit nor an independent verification.
Garnett was careful to stress the limits of the decision. Made at the motion-to-dismiss stage, the ruling required the court to accept well-pleaded allegations as true, and it does not establish that Chainalysis committed the conduct alleged.
From 1.18 billion USD to 3.3 billion USD
The dispute traces back to how Celsius arrived at the number it promoted in late 2020. According to the complaint summarized in the court's order, Celsius executive Timothy Cradle used Chainalysis's Reactor software on Nov. 2, 2020 and initially calculated assets under management of approximately 1.177 billion USD. Celsius insiders then allegedly changed the methodology — including accounting for the purported value of Celsius's own CEL token holdings — until the figure ballooned to roughly 3.3 billion USD.
On Dec. 9, 2020, Celsius publicly announced the completion of an "audit" confirming exactly 3,318,368,196.40 USD in assets using Chainalysis Reactor, describing the work as the platform's first third-party asset verification. Chainalysis executive Jason Bonds was quoted in the release saying the company had helped verify the process and accuracy of information connected with net funds collected by Celsius. The litigation administrator alleges that description was materially misleading, and the original release — with its language of "audit," "independent verification" and "third-party verification" — remains publicly available and central to the surviving claim.
In pari delicto argument fails, for now
Chainalysis had also argued that the estate should be blocked entirely under the doctrine of in pari delicto, which generally prevents a party from recovering damages for wrongdoing it participated in. Because BRIC stands in Celsius's shoes, the company contended, the claim should die with the lender's own misconduct. Garnett acknowledged the argument had force — noting Celsius could have received short-term benefits as CEL prices and customer numbers climbed — but said that at this stage the court must accept the complaint's allegation that insiders acted entirely for their own benefit. Because that factual dispute cannot be resolved from the complaint alone, the judge declined to dismiss Count One on that basis.
One piece of a larger recovery effort
The case is part of a wider scramble for recoveries after Celsius's 2022 collapse. BRIC filed the Chainalysis suit in March 2025; dismissal briefing concluded that July. In September, the estate separately sued BitMEX entities seeking roughly 6,360 BTC over March 2020 liquidations, coins valued near 495 million USD at filing. Those allegations also remain unproven.
Creditor distributions have continued in parallel. Celsius began a third payout worth 220.6 million USD in August 2025, lifting reported recoveries to 64.9 percent of eligible claims at the time. On the individual side, co-founders Shlomi Daniel Leon and Hanoch "Nuke" Goldstein agreed this year to pay a combined 6.5 million USD to settle Federal Trade Commission claims, while former CEO Alex Mashinsky is serving a 12-year prison sentence after pleading guilty to commodities and securities fraud.
Why the case matters beyond Celsius
The ruling is being watched closely across the crypto analytics industry. If the aiding-and-abetting claim survives to discovery, it could test how much exposure firms face when their tools, quotes or branding are attached to marketing claims by clients — a common practice in an industry where third-party "attestations" often substitute for formal audits. Chainalysis disputed the allegations and sought dismissal of the entire case; it can continue contesting liability as the suit moves beyond the pleading stage.
The next fixed deadline is Oct. 20, when BRIC must either amend the three consumer claims dismissed without prejudice or notify Judge Garnett that it will proceed without them. For a company whose business is measuring everyone else's onchain conduct, the irony of a prolonged court examination of its own 2020 press-release involvement is not lost on observers — and the outcome could shape how analytics firms police the difference between verification and marketing.
26 Comments