- Home
- Regulations
- LIBRA Class Action Thrown Out in New York: Why a Judge Ruled You Cannot Easily Sue a DeFi Protocol Like Meteora
LIBRA Class Action Thrown Out in New York: Why a Judge Ruled You Cannot Easily Sue a DeFi Protocol Like Meteora

The LIBRA memecoin scandal that engulfed Argentine President Javier Milei and wiped out millions of dollars from retail traders has just ended with a whimper in a New York courtroom — and the dismissal sets an uncomfortable precedent for anyone hoping to hold DeFi infrastructure accountable in the United States.
By Raj Patel | October 2, 2026
Table of Contents
The Hook: Dismissed With Prejudice
In a September 29 opinion and order from the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, Judge Jennifer L. Rochon granted motions to dismiss filed by Benjamin Chow — Meteora's co-founder and former CEO — and the Kelsier defendants, while Dynamic Labs secured dismissal of the claims brought against the Meteora protocol itself. The amended complaint was dismissed with prejudice, plaintiffs were denied permission to file a second amended complaint, and the clerk was directed to close the case, according to court documents reviewed by crypto.news.
The class action, filed in March 2025 by plaintiffs Omar Hurlock and Anuj Mehta, had accused Kelsier Labs, Hayden Davis, Gideon Davis, Thomas Davis, Meteora and Chow of fraud, conspiracy to defraud, violations of the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, violations of New York consumer protection law and unjust enrichment. Every one of those theories failed.
The Core Conflict: Can You Even Sue a Protocol?
The most consequential part of the ruling concerns Meteora's legal status. Dynamic Labs argued that Meteora was software rather than an unincorporated association or partnership. Plaintiffs countered by describing Meteora as an association made up of Chow and several other people and entities involved in developing and operating its programs on Solana.
Judge Rochon sided with the defense. Plaintiffs pointed to Meteora's team, governance arrangements, job postings and the multisignature process used to modify its software — but the court found those allegations did not establish the type of coordinated membership and common purpose required for an association under New York or federal law. The court similarly rejected the argument that Meteora could be treated as a partnership, leaving the plaintiffs unable to establish that the protocol had the legal existence required to be sued at all.
Chow Cleared, Kelsier Untouchable
Claims against Chow were dismissed separately under Rule 12(b)(6), which allows a court to toss claims that fail to state a legally sufficient case. Plaintiffs had alleged he worked with Kelsier on the M3M5 platform, provided technical support around token launches and assisted with Meteora's liquidity infrastructure before LIBRA went live. The court found that his knowledge of the launch, his technical assistance and the fees earned through the protocol were not enough to plausibly show fraudulent intent.
Chow had long maintained that Meteora's involvement in LIBRA was limited to technical support — comments on its liquidity curve and assistance verifying the token after launch — and acknowledged referring projects seeking deployment services to Kelsier while denying any role in LIBRA's development. He resigned from Meteora in February 2025 after questions emerged over the relationship, but the court's ruling now stands as a formal rejection of the fraud allegations against him.
The RICO claims against the Kelsier defendants failed on continuity grounds. The court found that the alleged activity, spanning roughly six months across M3M5 and LIBRA, did not satisfy the closed-ended or open-ended continuity required for a pattern of racketeering. Remaining state law claims against the Kelsier defendants were dismissed because the court concluded it lacked personal jurisdiction over them.
A Quick Refresher on the LIBRA Collapse
- February 14, 2025 — LIBRA launches on Solana.
- Same day — Argentine President Javier Milei posts about the project on X, linking to the Viva La Libertad website with the token's contract address. The price collapses hours later after a rush of trading.
- March 2025 — The class action is filed, alleging insiders withheld a large portion of LIBRA's supply and extracted funds after trading opened.
- May 2025 — Circle freezes roughly 57 million USDC linked to wallets at issue in the litigation.
- Later in 2025 — A U.S. court lifts the asset freeze after defendants agree not to move the disputed funds and plaintiffs withdraw their preliminary injunction request.
- September 29, 2026 — Judge Rochon dismisses the amended complaint with prejudice and closes the case.
Market Implications: The Argentina Thread Continues
The dismissal resolves the U.S. case, but not the wider LIBRA saga. Argentine authorities have continued examining the movement of funds connected to the launch, and in August 2026 a federal proceeding there remained ongoing. Milei deleted his original post hours after publishing it and said he had not known the project's details — an explanation that satisfied the court of public opinion in some quarters and infuriated it in others, but which now has little legal relevance in the United States.
The Verdict: A Warning for Retail Investors
For regular investors, the ruling delivers a sobering message: when a token launch goes wrong, the legal system may struggle to attach liability to decentralized infrastructure at all. If a protocol cannot easily be sued as an entity, and if individual defendants can defeat fraud claims by characterizing their role as "technical support," the practical protection available to buyers of a collapsed memecoin may be close to zero — regardless of how the launch was structured or who promoted it.
The courtroom is not the place to recover money lost to a hyped token with insider-heavy distribution. The only reliable defense is skepticism before you buy.
The cryptocurrency market remains highly volatile. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.
26 Comments